S3 Bucket via Route53 Troubles

So I've been hosting my static website through S3 Buckets to get started and it was going great but I made a quick switch to Lightsail to explore my options (resulting in switching back to S3) but now either my nameservers are wonky (since I did have to change them for lightsail) or I've missed something in my R53 settings.. It's honestly been over a week now and im at a loss for options.. Thoughts??

Domain: http://www.whenbrainsbleed.org

My endpoint still displays perfectly..
http://whenbrainsbleed.org.s3-website.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/

Any suggestions are appreciated

EDIT
Tried adjusting my S3 bucket policy - No luck.

Also not too confident in my record set Setup, I feel I could've messed those up somewhere along the way,

Record Sets:
-alias1
-alias2 (for www.)
(both linked directly to the S3 endpoint)
-CNAME (working on getting CloudFront implemented eventually)
-NS (Holds 3 nameservers in its value)
-SOA

Edited by: Martin-WBB on Jul 27, 2019 2:03 PM

Edited by: Martin-WBB on Jul 27, 2019 2:48 PM