The request could not be satisfied error coming from cloudfront

I'm getting this error when trying to call my API hosted on API Gateway:

<H2>The request could not be satisfied.</H2> Generated by cloudfront (CloudFront) Request ID: Vz-IregTgUHDPhDXhiu5b1LYit867fL4mIE9ZuOF8GoC-Ij66HGoig==

I seem to get this when calling an API from my local machine to hosted (but not local to localhost or hosted to hosted).

I'm using Chalice/API Gateway Developer Portal project (https://github.com/awslabs/aws-api-gateway-developer-portal/) I didn't set up anything in CloudFront myself and I don't see anything when I go to CloudFront in AWS console.

I'm also unsure if there are any rules for invoking API Gateway APIs from other API Gateway APIs. I have 2 chalice projects that I want to keep separate but for one to be able to call the other through REST API and both run in my same AWS account. Is there any issue with doing this?