Not able to install SSL certificate on EC2 server with complex IP setups

Hi Yogesh,

Thanks for sharing your question! Let’s dive into the details of your situation and outline a clear solution to configure SSL certificates for multiple domains hosted on IIS 10 in your EC2 Windows Server environment. This response also includes specific examples for managing multiple IPs and troubleshooting common SSL issues in IIS.

---

Clarifying the Issue

You’re hosting multiple websites on IIS 10 in an EC2 Windows instance, each bound to a different IP address. You want to install SSL certificates for these domains, ensuring secure HTTPS connections for each. However, it seems unclear how to configure this within AWS and IIS, particularly given your specific setup involving multiple IPs, VPCs, and subnets.

---

Key Terms

• SSL Certificate: A digital certificate that authenticates a website and enables encrypted communication over HTTPS.
• IIS 10: Internet Information Services version 10, a web server software developed by Microsoft.
• EC2 Instance: An Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud virtual server in the AWS cloud.
• VPC (Virtual Private Cloud): A private network for your AWS resources, including subnets and IP configurations.
• DNS Records: Entries in the Domain Name System that map domain names to IP addresses.
• AWS Certificate Manager (ACM): A service that allows you to provision, manage, and deploy SSL certificates on AWS resources like Load Balancers.

---

The Solution (Our Recipe)

Steps at a Glance:

1. Obtain individual SSL certificates or a wildcard certificate for your domains.
2. Import SSL certificates into the EC2 Windows Server.
3. Configure IIS bindings for each domain with its respective SSL certificate and IP address.
4. Automate the process for multiple IPs using PowerShell.
5. Verify DNS records for each domain to ensure correct IP resolution.
6. Adjust VPC and subnet configurations in AWS to match IIS setup and enable HTTPS traffic.
7. Validate HTTPS connections to ensure proper configuration.
8. Tighten security group rules to restrict access to trusted IPs.
9. Troubleshoot common SSL issues in IIS if necessary.

---

Step-by-Step Guide:

1. Obtain individual SSL certificates or a wildcard certificate for your domains.
   • Purchase SSL certificates from a trusted Certificate Authority (CA) or generate them through AWS Certificate Manager (ACM) if applicable.
   • If your domains share a common base (e.g., example.com and sub.example.com), consider using a wildcard certificate to simplify management.
   • Alternatively, use Let's Encrypt to obtain free SSL certificates.

---

2. Import SSL certificates into the EC2 Windows Server.

   • Convert the certificate files into the .pfx format if necessary (using tools like OpenSSL).
   • Import the .pfx files into the Windows certificate store via the IIS Manager or the certlm.msc utility.

   Example Command Using PowerShell:

   Import-PfxCertificate -FilePath "C:\path\to\certificate.pfx" -CertStoreLocation Cert:\LocalMachine\My

3. Configure IIS bindings for each domain with its respective SSL certificate and IP address.

   • Open IIS Manager and navigate to the “Sites” section.
   • Select each website and click “Bindings” on the right-hand side.
   • Add a new binding for HTTPS, specifying the corresponding IP address, port (443), and SSL certificate for the domain.
   • Ensure each domain uses a unique IP binding to avoid conflicts.

---

4. Automate the process for multiple IPs using PowerShell.

   PowerShell Script for IIS Bindings:

   $sites = @{
       "Site1" = "192.168.1.1";
       "Site2" = "192.168.1.2";
       "Site3" = "192.168.1.3"
   }
   foreach ($site in $sites.GetEnumerator()) {
       $siteName = $site.Key
       $ipAddress = $site.Value
       New-WebBinding -Name $siteName -IP $ipAddress -Port 443 -Protocol https
       # Assign the SSL certificate (replace "MyCertThumbprint" with the actual thumbprint)
       $cert = Get-ChildItem Cert:\LocalMachine\My | Where-Object { $_.Thumbprint -eq "MyCertThumbprint" }
       New-Item -Path "IIS:\SslBindings\$ipAddress!443" -Value $cert
   }

---

5. Verify DNS records for each domain to ensure correct IP resolution.
   • Ensure each domain’s DNS A or CNAME records point to the correct public IP address of your EC2 instance.
   • If managing DNS via AWS Route 53:
     • Go to the hosted zone for your domain.
     • Add or update A records for each domain and subdomain, mapping them to the corresponding public IPs.

---

6. Adjust VPC and subnet configurations in AWS to match IIS setup and enable HTTPS traffic.

   • Update your EC2 instance’s security groups to allow inbound traffic on port 443 for each IP.

   Example Command Using AWS CLI:

   aws ec2 authorize-security-group-ingress --group-id sg-12345678 \
       --protocol tcp --port 443 --cidr 0.0.0.0/0

   • For better security, replace 0.0.0.0/0 with trusted IP ranges to restrict access.

---

7. Validate HTTPS connections to ensure proper configuration.
   • Use a browser to test each domain by entering https://yourdomain.com.
   • Alternatively, use online SSL validation tools like SSL Labs to confirm proper installation and configuration.

---

8. Tighten security group rules to restrict access to trusted IPs.

   • After initial testing, replace broad CIDR ranges (0.0.0.0/0) with specific IP ranges or addresses that require access.

   Example Command Using AWS CLI:

   aws ec2 revoke-security-group-ingress --group-id sg-12345678 \
       --protocol tcp --port 443 --cidr 0.0.0.0/0
   aws ec2 authorize-security-group-ingress --group-id sg-12345678 \
       --protocol tcp --port 443 --cidr 203.0.113.0/24

---

9. Troubleshoot common SSL issues in IIS if necessary.

   • Issue: Certificate mismatch or "Untrusted Certificate Authority" errors.
     Solution: Verify that the correct certificate is bound to each site. Use PowerShell to list bindings:

     Get-WebBinding | Select-Object Name, BindingInformation, CertificateHash

   • Issue: Port 443 not accessible.
     Solution: Confirm that the security group allows inbound traffic on port 443 and that the Windows Firewall permits HTTPS connections.

   • Issue: DNS misconfiguration.
     Solution: Double-check DNS records and use tools like nslookup to verify domain-to-IP mappings.

---

Closing Thoughts

By following these steps, you can successfully install SSL certificates for all your domains hosted on IIS 10 in your EC2 Windows Server. The added PowerShell script simplifies managing multiple IPs, and the troubleshooting section addresses common roadblocks. Tightening security group rules and validating configurations will help ensure a secure and robust setup.

If you’re open to AWS-native solutions, consider using an Application Load Balancer (ALB) and AWS Certificate Manager (ACM) to centralize SSL management and reduce complexity.

Let us know if you need more help! 😊

---

Yogesh, I hope this updated guidance thoroughly addresses your needs. Best of luck with your configuration, and feel free to share any additional questions or progress updates. Have a great day! 🚀

---

Cheers, Aaron 😊