Skip to content

Subject: Severe Egress Packet Loss from us-east-1 to Hong Kong via PCCW Global Peering

0

I am experiencing severe asymmetric network performance on my Lightsail instance after migrating from Tokyo to us-east-1. Downloads from the server to Hong Kong are unusable due to packet loss on the return path.

Instance: engjmanga.jdbwizard.com (34.195.181.174) Access Location: Hong Kong

Performance Symptoms:

Download: 10 MB file takes 3+ minutes (effective speed <60 KB/s)

Upload: 10 MB file takes <10 seconds (~1 MB/s)

Web page load: 100 KB takes 50+ seconds

Root Cause Identified via MTR: The return path from us-east-1 to Hong Kong shows 86% packet loss at the Telia (AS1299) to PCCW Global peering point (hop 7 in mtr output below).

text HOST: ip-172-26-3-214 Loss% Snt Last Avg Best Wrst StDev 7.|-- pccwglobal-ic-386370... 86.0% 50 1.3 1.2 1.1 1.3 0.1 8.|-- Bundle-Ether40.br02... 6.0% 50 217.5 213.4 206.6 247.5 7.4

Request: Please investigate the egress routing from us-east-1 to Hong Kong and consider alternative peering paths that avoid this congested PCCW Global interconnect. Can traffic be routed via different transit providers with better connectivity to Asia?

Send this to AWS support. The 86% packet loss at a specific peering point is concrete evidence they can act on.

asked a year ago369 views

2 Answers
1

I understand you're experiencing severe network performance issues with your Lightsail instance in us-east-1 when connecting to Hong Kong, particularly with downloads being extremely slow while uploads are relatively normal.

Based on your MTR results, you've correctly identified a significant packet loss issue (86%) at the peering point between Telia (AS1299) and PCCW Global. This asymmetric routing problem is causing the poor download performance from your instance to Hong Kong.

IP traffic often traverses asymmetric paths, meaning the path your traffic takes to reach Hong Kong might be different from the return path. This can explain why uploads work well but downloads are problematic - the return path is experiencing severe congestion or routing issues.

For this specific issue, I recommend:

  1. Continue working with AWS Support as they can investigate the specific peering relationship and potentially adjust routing policies to avoid the problematic path.

  2. As a temporary workaround, you might consider:

  • Testing connectivity from a different AWS region that might have better routing to Hong Kong
  • Using a different instance type or networking option if available
  • Implementing a CDN solution for content delivery to Hong Kong users
  1. When communicating with AWS Support, share:
  • The complete bidirectional MTR results
  • Specific times when the issue occurs
  • Any patterns you've observed in the performance degradation

The high packet loss at a specific network hop is indeed concrete evidence that can help AWS Support investigate and potentially resolve the routing issue.
Sources
Diagnosing packet loss and latency with MTR | AWS re:Post
Network slow or unresponsible between central Europe and us-east-2 | AWS re:Post

answered a year ago

AWS
EXPERT

reviewed a year ago

0

As mentioned in the AI answer, you should definitely open a support case. re:Post is a community forum for advice from experts within the community and not a replacement for or path to AWS Support.

Separate from an actual issue with dropped traffic, I would suggest rethinking the move of your instance from Tokyo to us-east-1. If you have specific demand and performance requirements from Hong Kong or other APAC countries, us-east-1 is not going to be the best region to host your workload. You many be best served hosting the workload in multiple regions for servicing different geographies.

Finally, LightSail is great for getting started. If you get to the point where you need specific levels of performance you are likely outgrowing LightSail and would be best served by EC2 instances which have far more options for CPU/memory/disk/network etc.

Hope this helps.

AWS
EXPERT

answered a year ago

You are not logged in. Log in to post an answer.

A good answer clearly answers the question and provides constructive feedback and encourages professional growth in the question asker.