I am following this tutorial for MQTT messaging:
https://docs.aws.amazon.com/greengrass/v2/developerguide/client-devices-tutorial.html#develop-client-device-subscriber-component
I have 1 Client device associated with 2 Core devices (whereas the tutorial has 1 Client and 1 Core device, my understanding is that one-to-many should work as well). On both Core devices, I've deployed an aws.greengrass.clientdevices.mqtt.Bridge
with the following topic mapping:
"mqttTopicMapping": {
"HelloWorldIotCoreMapping": {
"topic": "test_topic",
"source": "LocalMqtt",
"target": "IotCore"
},
"HelloWorldPubsubMapping": {
"topic": "test_topic",
"source": "LocalMqtt",
"target": "Pubsub"
}
}
When sending messages using the tutorial's basic_discovery.py
script, I run the following command on both Core devices – and see messages being sent. That works great:
sudo /greengrass/v2/bin/greengrass-cli iotcore sub -t 'test_topic'
Result:
Successfully subscribed to topic: test_topic
{"message": "Hello World! ", "sequence": 0}
{"message": "Hello World! ", "sequence": 1}
...
But - when I re-run the discovery script on Client and run this command on both Core devices, only ONE of the two Core devices outputs the IPC messages
sudo /greengrass/v2/bin/greengrass-cli pubsub sub -t 'test_topic'
Why might the MQTT bridge relay be working on only one of the two Core devices? Deployments are identical on both Cores.
I'll call the Core device successfully receiving IPC messages device A, and the Core device receiving MQTT messages (but failing to receive IPC) device B. Something else I noticed — when I go to Core device A's console and disassociate the Client device from device A, the IPC messages immediately start coming up on device B.
Policies and selectionRule
in clientdevices.Auth
are definitely set correctly.
Also – as a test, I added a third Core device, device C. Now, only device C receives pubsub
messages, while all 3 devices continue to receive iotcore
messages. It's almost as if the MQTT bridge mapping is working on one of the three Core devices, at random.
I have tried:
- Reinstalling Greengrass core
- Restarting Greengrass service
- Restarting the MQTT / Moquette services
- Trying the same
basic_discovery
script on a different client device
Resolved; I didn't look at the implementation of basic_discovery.py closely enough, it just takes the first valid IoT endpoint connection and disregards the rest.