How to create subscription from an SNS to another SNS

1

I have a standard typed SNS. Can I create another SNS subscription from this SNS?

已提問 2 年前檢視次數 5224 次
3 個答案
1
已接受的答案

Hello,

Tim here from the AWS Support Team. As of today’s date, 04/21/2022, SNS supports the following (I'll circle back to your question further down):

  • Amazon Kinesis Data Firehose
  • Amazon SQS
  • AWS Lambda
  • Email
  • Email-JSON
  • HTTP
  • HTTPS
  • Platform application endpoint
  • SMS

For newer endpoints you can see the documentation here: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/sns/latest/dg/sns-create-subscribe-endpoint-to-topic.html

Now let’s circle back to your original question, can you add a SNS subscription to a SNS topic? Right now that isn't supported, however you could design workaround:

  • SNS and fanout to an additional lambda function, and then write a bit of code to push it to another SNS topic.

However, I think there may be a better approach here, where instead of having items published to your first SNS topic, you:

  • Publish it to EventBridge and fanout to multiple SNS resources. Would require a bit of testing to fully see if this is possible, but wanted to share it as a possible way forward. I viewed in my own EventBridge console if I could design an EventBridge rule with multiple SNS resources downstream and it appears possible, however I can't fully test all the quotas that would be specific to your application (you'd need to load test it and do careful examination of your system).

  • Publish to an AWS Lambda function first, then have the Lambda function write to multiple SNS resources. Keep in mind quotas again here, so load test!

  • The best option: wherever you're publishing messages to a SNS topic, just write it to the second SNS topic at the same time. I highly recommend this method. If a service is directly publishing to SNS so it's not some code doing the publishing, checkout EventBridge as a possible method again.

So to summarize a bit:

  • No direct support right now, sorry about that!
  • Workarounds exist, but takes careful evaluation and re-architecting. You'll want to keep in mind quotas, limits, throttling, for the specific workaround you choose.

Hope this helps out!

AWS
支援工程師
Tim_P
已回答 2 年前
profile picture
專家
已審閱 1 個月前
1

Hey Tim,

The approach Publish to an AWS Lambda function first, then have the Lambda function write to multiple SNS resources. Keep in mind quotas again here, so load test! fits best to me.

Thank you for this through explanation. Alper.

已回答 2 年前
0

Circling back, I found our AWS SDK doc examples that may help with writing that Lambda code: https://github.com/awsdocs/aws-doc-sdk-examples

If you're a fan of Python (Lambda goes great with Python with it's built in code editor for quick tests), I found a specific example: https://github.com/awsdocs/aws-doc-sdk-examples/blob/8ebb71d3a28fdb8ee8bd87b05d8475dfa29a0908/python/example_code/sns/sns_basics.py#L192

AWS
支援工程師
Tim_P
已回答 2 年前

您尚未登入。 登入 去張貼答案。

一個好的回答可以清楚地回答問題並提供建設性的意見回饋,同時有助於提問者的專業成長。

回答問題指南